| 1) Grace College |
165 |
| 2) Campbellsville University |
122 |
| 3) Bethel University |
119 |
| 4) Columbia International University |
99 |
| 5) Greenville University |
92 |
| 6) Westmont College |
50 |
| 7) York University |
46 |
| 8) University of Northwestern |
23 |
| 9) Concordia University Ann Arbor |
22 |
| T-10) Crown College |
21 |
| T-10) Geneva College |
21 |
| 12) Trinity Christian College |
17 |
| 13) Hannibal-LaGrange University |
13 |
| 14) Paine College |
10 |
| T-15) Southwestern Christian University |
8 |
| T-15) Bob Jones University |
8 |
| 17) College of the Ozarks |
6 |
| 18) Asbury University |
4 |
| 19) Judson University |
3 |
| T-20) Roberts Wesleyan University |
2 |
| T-20) Kentucky Christian University |
2 |
| T-20) Faith Baptist Bible College |
2 |
| T-23) Alice Lloyd College |
1 |
| T-23) North Central University |
1 |
| T-23) Wayland Baptist University |
1 |