| All-Tournament Team |
| Jose Barquin |
Bethel College |
| Romulo Barreto |
Columbia International University |
| Samuel Biek |
Bethel College |
| Luis Germano |
Judson University |
| Matheus Goveia |
Southwestern Christian University |
| Kurt Hamlin |
Grace College |
| Joel Hughes |
Lancaster Bible College |
| John Kanner |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Alex Koziolek |
Southwestern Christian University |
| Angelo Neto |
Warner University |
| Javier Verdu Sanchez |
Southwestern Christian University |
| Troy Walters |
Campbellsville University |
| |
| Tournament Most Outstanding Player |
| Matheus Goveia |
Southwestern Christian University |
| |
| Kyle Rote, Jr. Award |
| Omar Salgado |
Central Christian College of Kansas |
| |
| NCCAA Coach of the Year |
| Neil Cagle |
Southwestern Christian University |
| |
| United Soccer Coaches Coaching Staff of the Year |
| Southwestern Christian University |
| |
| NISOA Sportsmanship Award |
| Warner University |
| |
| Frank Jewell Award |
| Matthew Webb |
Houghton College |
| |
| United Soccer Coaches / NCCAA Player of the Year |
| Jamie Campbell |
Southwestern Christian University |
| |
| United Soccer Coaches All-America Team |
| Kurt Hamlin |
Grace College |
K |
| Gabe Hartwig |
North Central University |
K |
| Samuel Biek |
Bethel College |
D |
| John Kanner |
Ottawa University Arizona |
D |
| Javier Sanchez |
Southwestern Christian University |
D |
| Nick Standridge |
Pensacola Christian College |
D |
| Derek Braak |
Cedarville University |
M |
| Matheus Goveia |
Southwestern Christian University |
M |
| Finn Luben |
Bethel College |
M |
| Jorge Leon |
Grace Christian University |
M |
| Jamie Campbell |
Southwestern Christian University |
F |
| Igor Stojanovic |
Southwestern Christian University |
F |
| Cody Boerema |
Grace Colege |
F |
| Luis Germano |
Judson University |
F |
| Daniel Williams |
North Central University |
F |
| |
| NCCAA All-America First Team |
| Kurt Hamlin |
Grace College |
K |
| Samuel Biek |
Bethel College |
D |
| John Kanner |
Ottawa University Arizona |
D |
| Javier Sanchez |
Southwestern Christian University |
D |
| Derek Braak |
Cedarville University |
M |
| Matheus Goveia |
Southwestern Christian University |
M |
| Finn Luben |
Bethel College |
M |
| Jamie Campbell |
Southwestern Christian University |
F |
| Igor Stojanovic |
Southwestern Christian University |
F |
| Cody Boerema |
Grace College |
F |
| Luis Germano |
Judson University |
F |
| |
| NCCAA All-America Second Team |
| Luis Rodriguez |
Biola University |
K |
| Nathan Heath |
Campbellsville University |
D |
| Josiah Osborne |
Grace College |
D |
| Simon Weischmann |
Mid-America Christian University |
D |
| Oliver May |
Mid-America Christian University |
M |
| Breno Oliveira |
Grace College |
M |
| Tom Edge |
Campbellsville University |
M |
| Romulo Barretto |
Columbia International University |
M |
| Ulisses Miranda |
Grace College |
F |
| Marcos da Paz |
Columbia International University |
F |
| Troy Walters |
Campbellsville University |
F |
| |
| NCCAA All-America Third Team |
| Carter Selvius |
Cedarville University |
K |
| Kyle McDowell |
Ottawa University Arizona |
D |
| Nick Jackson |
Southwestern Christian University |
D |
| James Feehan |
Warner University |
D |
| Kousei Mattox |
Biola University |
M |
| Alex Koziolek |
Southwestern Christian University |
M |
| Atu Galadima |
Biola University |
M |
| Hazem Sobhy |
Ottawa University Arizona |
M |
| Nikolas Mihalopolous |
Judson University |
F |
| Leo Thompson |
Biola University |
F |
| Danny Cameron |
Emmanuel College |
F |
| |
| Scholar-Athletes |
| Samuel Biek |
Bethel College |
| Rene Collazos |
Bethel College |
| Gabriel Ferreira |
Bethel College |
| Elijah Kerr |
Bethel College |
| Finn Luben |
Bethel College |
| Billy Mittard |
Bethel College |
| Lucas Moreira |
Bethel College |
| Isaac Nunez |
Bethel College |
| Zach Schoon |
Bethel College |
| Jake Munivez |
Biola University |
| Alejandro Pelayo |
Biola University |
| Parker Setran |
Biola University |
| Axel Van Cleve |
Biola University |
| Sven Kleinhans |
Bluefield College |
| Kevin Stoffle |
Bluefield College |
| Martin Alvez |
Brewton-Parker College |
| Doran Battermann |
Columbia International University |
| Noah Shaver |
Columbia International University |
| Jacob Campbell |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Jonathan Detwiler |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Bryce Pederson |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Jeffrey Thomas |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Spencer Ward |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Juan Zambrano |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Nico Becker |
Emmanuel College |
| Deibyd Contreras |
Emmanuel College |
| Marcus Larsen |
Emmanuel College |
| Channing Park |
Emmanuel College |
| Blair Springhall |
Emmanuel College |
| Henrique Cerruti |
Grace College |
| Joshua Coupar |
Grace College |
| Kurt Hamlin |
Grace College |
| Zeb Andre Johansson |
Grace College |
| Santiago Maya |
Grace College |
| Ulisses Miranda |
Grace College |
| Togo Narusawa |
Grace College |
| Breno Oliveira |
Grace College |
| Josiah Osborn |
Grace College |
| Gabriel Osti |
Grace College |
| Charles Dalton |
Greenville University |
| Nicholas Holland |
Greenville University |
| Ian Maclean |
Greenville University |
| Caleb Mulholland |
Greenville University |
| Emmanuel Nava |
Greenville University |
| Renan Obayashi |
Greenville University |
| Max Schimmelpfenning |
Greenville University |
| Daniel Weyers |
Greenville University |
| Diego Beltramin |
Hannibal-LaGrange University |
| Marcus Betzer |
Houghton College |
| Daniel Bussey |
Houghton College |
| Benjamin DiCastro |
Houghton College |
| Caleb Kaiss |
Houghton College |
| Josiah Kratz |
Houghton College |
| Lars Ljungholm |
Houghton College |
| Darcy Mitchell |
Houghton College |
| Joel Mulindwa |
Houghton College |
| Jeremy Newswanger |
Houghton College |
| Christian Scott |
Houghton College |
| Zachary Shilvock |
Houghton College |
| Michael Brand |
Lincoln Christian University |
| Djbril Fofana |
Mid-America Christian University |
| Oliver May |
Mid-America Christian University |
| Roger Peron |
Mid-America Christian University |
| Sergio Ribeiro |
Mid-America Christian University |
| Gustavo Cardier |
Oakland City University |
| Jack Cookson |
Oakland City University |
| Matthew Doty |
Oakland City University |
| Carlo Diaz Madrid |
Oakland City University |
| Jacob Cashour |
Southern Wesleyan University |
| Romanov Jean |
Southern Wesleyan University |
| Zach Smith |
Southern Wesleyan University |
| Chris Thorman |
Southwestern Assemblies of God University |
| Dylan Busscher |
Trinity Christian College |
| Tyler Massa |
Trinity Christian College |
| Tate Rozeveld |
Trinity Christian College |
| Gabriel Soler |
Trinity Christian College |
| Case VanWingerden |
Trinity Christian College |
| Josh Austriaco |
Trinity International University |
| Aaron Gerdes |
Trinity International University |
| Michael Linsner |
Trinity International University |
| Kyle McNamara |
Trinity International University |
| Eddie Windsor |
Trinity International University |
| Austin Heil |
University of Northwestern |
| Josh Robertson |
University of Northwestern |
| Kenolson Collin |
Warner University |
| James Feehan |
Warner University |
| James Flaming |
Warner University |
| Joel Flaming |
Warner University |
| Devyn Hencil |
Warner University |
| Donovan Ingley |
Warner University |
| Austin Steen |
Warner University |