| Offensive Player of the Year |
| Jakwon Roberts |
Kentucky Christian University |
| |
| Defensive Player of the Year |
| Ryan Fish |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| |
| All-NCCAA First Team Offense |
| Jakwon Roberts |
Kentucky Christian University |
QB |
| Shamar Moreland |
Ottawa University Arizona |
RB |
| De'Anta Sipp |
Kentucky Christian University |
RB |
| Luke Wilson |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
TE |
| Deon Cook |
Trinity International University |
WR |
| Gino Mastandrea |
Trinity International University |
WR |
| Tate Pringle |
Campbellsville University |
WR |
| Caleb Muxlow |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
OL |
| Tristan Shehorn |
Ottawa University Arizona |
OL |
| Jonas Small |
Warner University |
OL |
| Dartanyan Tinsley |
Kentucky Christian University |
OL |
| James Williams |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
OL |
| Luis Gomez |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
PK |
| Shamar Moreland |
Ottawa University Arizona |
RET |
| |
| All-NCCAA Second Team Offense |
| Nolan Brammer |
Trinity International University |
QB |
| Keviontae Brown |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
RB |
| Paul Garrett |
Greenville University |
RB |
| Brendan Ray |
Kentucky Christian University |
TE |
| Parker Graham |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
WR |
| Jeremiah Greylock |
Ottawa University Arizona |
WR |
| Senika McKie |
Erskine College |
WR |
| Diego Soto |
Kentucky Christian University |
WR |
| Elijah Boyd-Volakis |
Ottawa University Arizona |
OL |
| Christian Ealey |
Kentucky Christian University |
OL |
| Sam Fitch |
Greenville University |
OL |
| Samuel Laga |
Ottawa University Arizona |
OL |
| Tanner Sims |
Warner University |
OL |
| Landon Reeves |
Ottawa University Arizona |
PK |
| Seeger DeGayner |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
RET |
| |
| All-NCCAA First Team Defense |
| James Castleberry |
Kentucky Christian University |
DL |
| Micah Corley |
Campbellsville University |
DL |
| Andrew Foerster |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
DL |
| Alex Hinojosa |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
DL |
| Jon Carrothers |
Campbellsville University |
LB |
| Anthony Grant |
Kentucky Christian University |
LB |
| David Jones, Jr. |
Ottawa University Arizona |
LB |
| Kemon Reese |
Trinity International University |
LB |
| De'Andre Armstrong |
Ottawa University Arizona |
DB |
| Lorente Blakeney |
Trinity International University |
DB |
| Ryan Fish |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
DB |
| Trey Malashevich |
Kentucky Christian University |
DB |
| Austin Bohn |
Ottawa University Arizona |
P |
| |
| All-NCCAA Second Team Defense |
| Seth Ham |
Ottawa University Arizona |
DL |
| Moses Smith |
Trinity International University |
DL |
| David Sow |
Ottawa University Arizona |
DL |
| Christian Viville |
Ottawa University Arizona |
DL |
| Andrew Bennett |
Campbellsville University |
LB |
| Rylen Kaniaupio |
Ottawa University Arizona |
LB |
| Hunter Maynard |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
LB |
| Aaron Rahn |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
LB |
| Conner Long |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
DB |
| Kobe Reese |
Campbellsville University |
DB |
| Malcolm Walker |
Campbellsville University |
DB |
| Corey Watkins |
Trinity International University |
DB |
| Casey Rauch |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
P |
| |
| Scholar-Athletes |
| Jon Carrothers |
Campbellsville University |
| Blake Coffman |
Campbellsville University |
| Austin Bohn |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Elijah Boyd-Volakis |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Kevon Owens |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Shaun Richards |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Tristan Shehorn |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Hokulani Wickard |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Dillon Patrick |
Trinity International University |
| Tate Bounds |
University of Northwestern |
| Asa Champion |
University of Northwestern |
| Cameron Coppock |
University of Northwestern |
| Jacob Emley |
University of Northwestern |
| Nathan Fenske |
University of Northwestern |
| Levi Johnson |
University of Northwestern |
| Luke LeBrun |
University of Northwestern |
| Blake Mitchell |
University of Northwestern |
| Jeremiah Pedro |
University of Northwestern |
| Travaris Ricks |
University of Northwestern |
| Parker Schmidgall |
University of Northwestern |
| Caleb Sieben |
University of Northwestern |