| Wheeler Award |
| Sim Kiser |
Campbellsville University |
| |
|
| Coach of the Year |
| Jake Poyner |
Grace College |
| |
|
| All-Americans |
| Bryan Hernandez-Rios |
Grace College |
| Logan Rufenacht |
Grace College |
| Irakoze Janvier |
College of the Ozarks |
| Trevor Miller |
Bethel University |
| Justin Van Prooyen |
Grace College |
| Brandon Kleber |
Grace College |
| Alec Whitener |
Hannibal-LaGrange University |
| Cyle Butenhoff |
Hannibal-LaGrange University |
| Macallister Cheek |
Grace College |
| Isaac Beatty |
Grace College |
| |
|
| Scholar-Athletes |
| Dallas Kastens |
Asbury University |
| Stuart Kirkbride |
Asbury University |
| Ian Wilkinson |
Asbury University |
| Evan Brown |
Bethel University |
| Kent Eagleson |
Bethel University |
| Josiah Railton |
Bethel University |
| Jacob Ropp |
Bethel University |
| Jacob Hamilton |
Campbellsville University |
| Collin Sheffield |
Campbellsville University |
| Briley Shrewsberry |
Campbellsville University |
| Trevor Cross |
Cedarville University |
| Colin Cramer |
Cedarville University |
| Abram Enns |
Cedarville University |
| Isaiah Kelly |
Cedarville University |
| Adam Klauck |
Cedarville University |
| Cooper Peterson |
Cedarville University |
| Mason Apperson |
College of the Ozarks |
| Garrett Pierce |
College of the Ozarks |
| Tavarress Berrian |
Columbia International University |
| Josiah Helmer |
Geneva College |
| Dakota Ames |
Grace College |
| Isaac Beatty |
Grace College |
| Macallister Cheek |
Grace College |
| Bryan Hernandez-Rios |
Grace College |
| Zachary Johnson |
Grace College |
| Dimitiros Margartidis |
Grace College |
| Logan Rufenacht |
Grace College |
| Kyle Smith |
Grace College |
| Eli Atkins |
Greenville University |
| Isaiah Atkins |
Greenville University |
| Seth Greene |
Houghton College |
| David Russo |
Houghton College |
| Lucas Clark |
Malone University |
| Michael Collins |
Malone University |
| Noah Harper |
Malone University |
| Steven Hennis |
Malone University |
| Nicholas Michels |
Malone University |
| Matt Parker |
Malone University |
| Graham Scott |
Malone University |
| Noah Booze |
Ohio Christian University |
| Chester Mientkiewicz |
Ohio Christian University |
| Anthony Reppermann |
Trinity Christian College |
| Ben Lundsten |
University of Northwestern |
| Tristan Thompson |
University of Northwestern |
| David Herrera |
Warner University |
| Joel Zaila |
Warner University |