| All-Tournament Team |
| Kolby Campbell |
Central Christian College of Kansas |
| Alex Costa |
Trinity Christian College |
| Colin Donisthorpe |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Phillip Holbrook |
Maranatha Baptist University |
| Jake Ostema |
Trinity Christian College |
| Emery Outin |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Curtis Thomas |
Geneva College |
| |
|
| Tournament Most Outstanding Player |
| Colin Donisthorpe |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| |
|
| Scholar-Athletes |
| Drew Sims |
Campbellsville University |
| Bastiaan Van Houten |
Campbellsville University |
| Brady Bartlett |
Carolina University |
| Ronald Smart |
Carolina University |
| Peter Barbato |
Geneva College |
| James O'Donnell |
Geneva College |
| Sam Parsons |
Geneva College |
| Byron Spear |
Geneva College |
| Caleb Vander Plaats |
Geneva College |
| Jake Williams |
Geneva College |
| Greg Geake |
Judson University |
| Cameron Hacker |
Judson University |
| Brody Solbrig |
Judson University |
| Peter Holloway |
Maranatha Baptist University |
| Zachary Mueller |
Maranatha Baptist University |
| Drew Smith |
Maranatha Baptist University |
| Peyton Warner |
Maranatha Baptist University |
| Conner Duyck |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| John Estrada |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Steven Grandinetti |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Tatum Gray |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Jordan Moses |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Blake Music |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Daniel Velasquez-Wilson |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Jose Gonzalez |
Warner University |