| Elvin and Joyce King Award |
| Samuel Bennett |
Campbellsville University |
| |
|
| Coach of the Year |
| Corbin Harris |
Campbellsville University |
| |
|
| All-Americans |
| Dominic Malel |
Campbellsville University |
| Evans Pololet |
Wayland Baptist University |
| Jace Sanchez |
Wayland Baptist University |
| Hayden Schmidt |
Malone University |
| Lukas Smithson |
Campbellsville University |
| Jaden Rodriguez |
Mid-America Christian University |
| Martin Batel |
Campbellsville University |
| David Hernandez |
Wayland Baptist University |
| Alex Hill |
Malone University |
| Tanner Bailey |
College of the Ozarks |
| |
|
| Scholar-Athletes |
| Tyler Chong |
Asbury University |
| Luke Holton |
Asbury University |
| Dan Kersey |
Asbury University |
| Aaron Douglass |
Bethel University |
| Logan Mann |
Bethel University |
| Ethan Callarman |
Cedarville University |
| Rylan Felumlee |
Cedarville University |
| Andrew Ferradino |
Cedarville University |
| Collin Gilmour |
Cedarville University |
| Jeremiah Hetrick |
Cedarville University |
| Nathan Lewis |
Cedarville University |
| Aidan Peterson |
Cedarville University |
| Levi Robinson |
Cedarville University |
| Jonathan Varner |
Cedarville University |
| Caleb Yun |
Cedarville University |
| Alex Frizzell |
College of the Ozarks |
| Drew Rose |
College of the Ozarks |
| Josh Zhang |
Columbia International University |
| Luke Bentz |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Kevin Arseneaux |
Geneva College |
| Archie McKissick |
Geneva College |
| Carter Clear |
Grace College |
| Ian Harrold |
Grace College |
| Ryun Hoffert |
Grace College |
| Cole Johnston |
Grace College |
| Hayden Mullett |
Grace College |
| Kyle Robinson |
Grace College |
| Justin Van Prooyen |
Grace College |
| Harrison Wealing |
Grace College |
| Amos Bixler |
Houghton University |
| James Eustace |
Houghton University |
| Isaac Gasparri |
Houghton University |
| Sam Lyon |
Houghton University |
| Devon Hammeke |
Jessup University |
| Zachary Heberlein |
Jessup University |
| Chase Ashcraft |
Judson University |
| Kyle Braund |
Judson University |
| Gage Fox |
Judson University |
| Joseph Benedict |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Dustin Frantz |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Mitchell Gray |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Daniel Lefko |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Mason Ackley |
Malone University |
| Chase Balko |
Malone University |
| Noah Blaz |
Malone University |
| Jacob Cureton |
Malone University |
| Eric Dehmer |
Malone University |
| Hayden Schmidt |
Malone University |
| Tyler Twining |
Malone University |
| Ethan Hillis |
Mid-America Christian University |
| Trevor Searls |
Nelson University |
| Evan Caldwell |
Ohio Christian University |
| Corry Mientkiewicz |
Ohio Christian University |
| Jason Springer |
Ohio Christian University |
| Masen Hoffman |
OUAZ |
| Michael Kulek |
OUAZ |
| Evan Davis |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Zachary Hall |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Bryce Myers |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Owen White |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Dawson Urwiller |
Sterling College |
| Christian Contreras |
Trinity Christian College |
| Jesus Portilla |
Trinity Christian College |
| Luke Rotman |
Trinity Christian College |
| Bennett Selfridge |
University of Northwestern |
| Owen Van De Riet |
University of Northwestern |
| Jacob Weddle |
University of Northwestern |