| Tournament Most Outstanding Player |
| Jan Lopuch |
Jessup University |
|
|
| All-Tournament Team |
| Gaston Barrionuevo |
Oakland City University |
| Landon Brouwer |
Jessup University |
| Carter Depue |
Jessup University |
| Noah Liousfi |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Jan Lopuch |
Jessup University |
| Taylor Marks |
Jessup University |
| Elijah Wrobel |
Judson University |
|
|
| Game Plan 4 LIFE Award |
| Elijah Wrobel |
Judson University |
|
| NCCAA Coach of the Year |
| Kyle Steele |
Jessup University |
|
| NCCAA Player of the Year |
| Jan Lopuch |
Jessup University |
|
| NCCAA All-America First Team |
| Jan Lopuch |
Jessup University |
| Thomas Dunkley |
Bethel University |
| Landon Brouwer |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Darion Graham |
Warner University |
| Elijah Wrobel |
Judson University |
| Kevin Bryant |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Owen Henning |
Jessup University |
|
| NCCAA All-America Second Team |
| Alonzo Vega |
Campbellsville University |
| Oscar Jaquez |
Warner University |
| Paul Fillion |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Mason McKinney |
Campbellsville University |
| Taylor Marks |
Jessup University |
| Gaston Barrionuevo |
Oakland City University |
| Simon Bourne |
Redeemer University |
|
| Scholar-Athletes |
| Timofey Borodkin |
Bethel University |
| Nicholas Campeau |
Bethel University |
| McGwire Eigenrauch |
Bethel University |
| Jackson Hughes |
Bethel University |
| Erik Malek |
Bethel University |
| Mark Moore |
Bethel University |
| Ben Ritzema |
Bethel University |
| Landon Sears |
Bethel University |
| David Barcan |
Campbellsville University |
| Moritz Frauendorg |
Campbellsville University |
| Andrew Steinmentz |
Campbellsville University |
| Freidrich Hall |
Carolina University |
| Paul O'Donnell |
Geneva College |
| Evan Puhl |
Geneva College |
| Josh Sangrey |
Geneva College |
| Andrew Ubinger |
Geneva College |
| Devin Burns |
Houghton University |
| Luke George |
Houghton University |
| Thomas McGlynn |
Houghton University |
| Elijah Wrobel |
Judson University |
| Zach Herb |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Nicolas Marion |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Tyler Martin |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Mac Swineford |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Zach Wyant |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Caleb Goetz |
Maranatha Baptist University |
| Troy Jones |
Maranatha Baptist University |
| Hazem Abdelghafar |
Oakland City University |
| Maycor Carrion |
Oakland City University |
| Michael Fenley |
Oakland City University |
| Ariel Fokoua |
Oakland City University |
| Hugo Gonzalez |
Oakland City University |
| Danilo Negrao |
Oakland City University |
| Jaskaran Singh |
OUAZ |
| Johnathan Worden |
OUAZ |
| Frederick Breukelman |
Redeemer University |
| Ben Siebenga |
Redeemer University |
| Davis Young |
Redeemer University |
| Keith Larkin |
Regent University |
| Preston Nemeti |
Regent University |
| Colby Yawn |
Regent University |
| Jonah Grbic |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Griffin Monrad |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| James Methot |
Warner University |