| Scholar-Athletes |
| Jacob Curry |
Alice Lloyd College |
| Micah Shelton |
Alice Lloyd College |
| Jonathan Combs |
Asbury University |
| Tyler Hall |
Asbury University |
| Cameron Jones |
Asbury University |
| Jordan Lewis |
Asbury University |
| Scott Shepherd |
Asbury University |
| Turner Shouse |
Asbury University |
| Bruce Snellen |
Asbury University |
| Jonathan Wright |
Asbury University |
| Colin Comer |
Bethel University |
| Austin Cripe |
Bethel University |
| Beau Jacquay |
Bethel University |
| Luke McBride |
Bethel University |
| Alonas Peciulis |
Bethel University |
| Kevin Enriquez |
Bethesda University |
| Gustavo Goncalves |
Bethesda University |
| Remington Green |
Bethesda University |
| Chukwudi Okoli |
Bethesda University |
| Edward Spencer |
Bethesda University |
| Miles Sulka |
Bethesda University |
| Omar Tovar |
Bethesda University |
| Devan Edwards |
Carolina University |
| Balsa Folic |
Carolina University |
| Myles Randolph |
Carolina University |
| Enock Rosil |
Carolina University |
| Dashaun Stigler |
Carolina University |
| Mikail Harmison |
Cedarville University |
| Trevor Ruble |
Cedarville University |
| Anthony Ruffolo |
Cedarville University |
| Braden Woodall |
Cedarville University |
| Reece Johnson |
College of the Ozarks |
| Tyler Moore |
College of the Ozarks |
| Zach Everly |
Columbia International University |
| Dominic Phillips |
Columbia International University |
| JJ Vaughan |
Columbia International University |
| Johnny Whysong |
Columbia International University |
| Nate Hauglie |
Ecclesia College |
| Caleb Herrold |
Grace College |
| Seth Matin |
Grace College |
| Ian Raasch |
Grace College |
| Isaac Schultz |
Grace College |
| Gage Sefton |
Grace College |
| Hunter Walston |
Grace College |
| Jair Bialek |
Houghton University |
| Zachary Sisson |
Houghton University |
| Bronson Bartuch |
Judson University |
| Joe Hazelwood |
Judson University |
| Quintin Sewell |
Kansas Christian College |
| Drew Napier |
Kentucky Christian University |
| D'Angelo Stoxstill |
Kentucky Christian University |
| Jake Bruns |
Malone University |
| Jailin Johnson |
Malone University |
| Josiah Pierre |
Malone University |
| Nic Williams |
Malone University |
| Orlando Gonzales |
Nelson University American Indian College |
| Chase Pavey |
Nelson University American Indian College |
| Xavier Santacasa |
OUAZ |
| Quinn Thorne |
OUAZ |
| Jeremiah Della Foresta |
Redeemer University |
| Jackson Thackwray |
Redeemer University |
| Joshua Vogt |
Regent University |
| Camryn Reed |
Southwestern Christian University |
| Camden Carr |
Sterling College |
| Garrett Greene |
Trinity Christian College |
| Christopher Henthorn |
Trinity Christian College |
| Quinton Hunter |
Trinity Christian College |
| John Kveck |
Trinity Christian College |
| Ognjen Petkovic |
Trinity Christian College |
| Jacob Spaulding |
Trinity Christian College |
| Silas Spaulding |
Trinity Christian College |
| Daniel Staskunas |
Trinity Christian College |
| Jonah Burnett |
University of Northwestern |
| Will Foster |
University of Northwestern |
| AJ Greene |
University of Northwestern |
| Jacob Hoefs |
University of Northwestern |
| Ben Tschida |
University of Northwestern |
| Joshua Irwin |
Warner University |
| Jason Ogbolu |
Warner University |
| Cameron Thomas |
Warner University |
| Jackson Voth |
Warner University |
| Brett Leach |
Wayland Baptist University |
| Grady Galyean |
Wayland Baptist University |
| Dylan McDougal |
Wayland Baptist University |