| Elvin and Joyce King Award |
| Tyler Twining |
Malone University |
| |
|
| Coach of the Year |
| Zach Fresenko |
Malone University |
| |
|
| All-Americans |
| Tanner Bailey |
College of the Ozarks |
| Hayden Schmidt |
Malone University |
| Martin Batel |
Campbellsville University |
| Yahya Jawadi |
Malone University |
| Lucky Maila |
Mid-America Christian University |
| Jaden Rodriguez |
Mid-America Christian University |
| Nathan Sury |
Campbellsville University |
| Wyatt Royster |
Malone University |
| Zavier Medina |
Malone University |
| Xander Heil |
Malone University |
| |
|
| Scholar-Athletes |
| JoJo Ernst |
Asbury University |
| Daniel Kersey |
Asbury University |
| Josh Rittgers |
Asbury University |
| Aaron Douglass |
Bethel University |
| Benjamin Keller |
Bethel University |
| Logan Mann |
Bethel University |
| Anthony Maxwell |
Bethel University |
| Elijah Poorman |
Bethel University |
| Martin Batel |
Campbellsville University |
| Samuel Johnson |
Campbellsville University |
| Samuel Larson |
Campbellsville University |
| Joseph Carroll IV |
Cedarville University |
| Rylan Felumlee |
Cedarville University |
| Andrew Ferradino |
Cedarville University |
| Jeremiah Hetrick |
Cedarville University |
| Camden Johnecheck |
Cedarville University |
| Finn Kraft |
Cedarville University |
| Nathan Lewis |
Cedarville University |
| Taylor Plank |
Cedarville University |
| Caleb Sultan |
Cedarville University |
| Jonathan Varner |
Cedarville University |
| Isaac Wallis |
Cedarville University |
| Caleb Yun |
Cedarville University |
| Alex Frizzel |
College of the Ozarks |
| Drew Rose |
College of the Ozarks |
| Josh Zhang |
Columbia International University |
| Carter Clear |
Grace College |
| Ian Harrold |
Grace College |
| Ryun Hoffert |
Grace College |
| Cole Johnston |
Grace College |
| Luis Loera-Arambula |
Grace College |
| Aden McCarty |
Grace College |
| Caleb Nichols |
Grace College |
| Kyle Robinson |
Grace College |
| Luke Schramm |
Grace College |
| John Young |
Grace College |
| Tyler Johnson |
Greenville University |
| Amos Bixler |
Houghton University |
| Sam Cobb |
Houghton University |
| Luke Ellis |
Houghton University |
| Isaac Gasparri |
Houghton University |
| Sam Van Huss |
Kentucky Christian University |
| Dustin Frantz |
Lancaster Bible College |
| David Helms |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Caleb Woods |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Noah Blaz |
Malone University |
| Eric Dehmer |
Malone University |
| Luke Dininger |
Malone University |
| Xander Heil |
Malone University |
| Brylan Holland |
Malone University |
| Henry Hoover |
Malone University |
| Kellen Reichert |
Malone University |
| Hayden Schmidt |
Malone University |
| Jack Swartz |
Malone University |
| Zack Tribelo |
Malone University |
| Tyler Twining |
Malone University |
| Jesus Flores |
Nelson University |
| Pierce Lashley |
Oakland City University |
| Michael Kulek |
OUAZ |
| Trevor Heitkamp |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Charles Matzke |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Demario Angarita |
Trinity Christian College |
| Jeremiah Klompien |
Trinity Christian College |
| Aitor Moya |
Trinity Christian College |
| Jesus Portilla |
Trinity Christian College |
| Luke Rotman |
Trinity Christian College |
| Tyler Deuber |
University of Northwestern |
| Samuel Otis |
University of Northwestern |
| Joshua Ringsmuth |
University of Northwestern |
| Owen Van De Riet |
University of Northwestern |
| Marcus McLemore |
Wayland Baptist University |
| Jaden Beske |
York University |