| Offensive Player of the Year |
| Paul Garrett |
Greenville University |
| |
|
| Defensive Player of the Year |
| Hunter Maynard |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| |
|
| All-NCCAA First Team Offense |
| Jordan Barlow |
Southwestern Assemblies of God University |
QB |
| Keaton Dudik |
Southwestern Assemblies of God University |
RB |
| Paul Garrett |
Greenville University |
RB |
| Chance Whitehead |
Sterling College |
WR |
| O'Vauntay Vickers |
Judson University |
WR |
| Brandon McLaughlin |
Ottawa University Arizona |
WR |
| Luke Wilson |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
TE |
| Antuan McDowell |
Southwestern Assemblies of God University |
OL |
| Dustin Rivera |
Ottawa University Arizona |
OL |
| Jonas Small |
Warner University |
OL |
| Layne Becker |
Sterling College |
OL |
| Nomar Laurel |
Ottawa University Arizona |
OL |
| Michael Hall |
Ottawa University Arizona |
PK |
| Shamar Moreland |
Ottawa University Arizona |
RS |
| |
|
| All-NCCAA First Team Defense |
| Turjon McLaurin |
Greenville University |
DL |
| Levi Rodriguez |
Southwestern Assemblies of God University |
DL |
| Andrew Foerster |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
DL |
| Quis Icon |
Crown College |
DL |
| Hunter Maynard |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
LB |
| Brandon Tomerlin Jr. |
Ottawa University Arizona |
LB |
| Kemon Reese |
Trinity International University |
LB |
| Casey Rauch |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
LB |
| Isaac Gowdy |
Southwestern Assemblies of God University |
DB |
| Kwame Sexton |
Sterling College |
DB |
| Gerald McHenry Jr. |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
DB |
| Lorente Blakeney |
Trinity International University |
DB |
| Casey Rauch |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
P |
| |
|
| All-NCCAA Second Team Offense |
| Austin McCullough |
Ottawa University Arizona |
QB |
| D'Anta Sipp |
Campbellsville University |
RB |
| Marcelous Chester-Riley |
Ottawa University Arizona |
RB |
| Cole Mistretta |
Crown College |
WR |
| Parker Graham |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
WR |
| Kevin Davis |
Warner University |
WR |
| Janson Robeson |
Sterling College |
TE |
| Austin Lloyd |
Ottawa University Arizona |
OL |
| Hayden Evans |
Southwestern Assemblies of God University |
OL |
| Nathan Roehr |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
OL |
| Will Dowling |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
OL |
| Derek Martinez-Delgado |
Greenville University |
OL |
| Kieran Woodley |
Southwestern Assemblies of God University |
PK |
| Hilton McClain Jr. |
Geneva College |
RS |
| |
|
| All-NCCAA Second Team Defense |
| Keandre Belcher |
Southwestern Assemblies of God University |
DL |
| George Obitz |
University of Northwestern |
DL |
| Christian Viville |
Ottawa University Arizona |
DL |
| Clifton Jimerson |
Judson University |
DL |
| Aaron Rahn |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
LB |
| David Jones Jr. |
Ottawa University Arizona |
LB |
| Jonathan Jones |
Warner University |
LB |
| Lakari Benjamin |
Warner University |
LB |
| De'Andre Armstrong |
Ottawa University Arizona |
DB |
| Rudy Criner |
Crown College |
DB |
| James Clark |
Geneva College |
DB |
| Isaac Green |
Greenville University |
DB |
| Austin Bohn |
Ottawa University Arizona |
P |
| |
|
| Victory Bowl Most Outstanding Offensive Player |
| Jordan Barlow |
Southwestern Assemblies of God University |
| |
| Victory Bowl Most Outstanding Defensive Player |
| Brayden Lock |
Sterling College |
| |
|
| Scholar-Athletes |
| Lane Bottoms |
Campbellsville University |
| Zachary Cole |
Campbellsville University |
| Chase Elmore |
Campbellsville University |
| Ethan Gossage |
Campbellsville University |
| Ethan White |
Campbellsville University |
| Zachary Belinsky |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Shayne Erni |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Andrew Foerster |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Hunter Maynard |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Jake Mlynarek |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Nicholas Painter |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Connor Scribner |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| John Shutt |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Corbin Stefanski |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Andrew Wiemer |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Maxwell Wood |
Concordia University Ann Arbor |
| Ugo Egwin |
Crown College |
| Jared Gilmore |
Crown College |
| Josh Wallace |
Crown College |
| Zach Almy |
Geneva College |
| Lester Boots |
Geneva College |
| Louie Delcolle |
Geneva College |
| Dustin Kingsley |
Geneva College |
| Amos Luptak |
Geneva College |
| Jared Ozias |
Geneva College |
| Jaiden Sanu-Owens |
Geneva College |
| Peyton Schell |
Geneva College |
| Haddon Schlarbaum |
Geneva College |
| Ryan Erickson |
Judson University |
| Austin Bohn |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Connor Knudson |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Elijah Boyd-Volakis |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Jack Sanderson |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Kevon Owens |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Shaun Richards |
Ottawa University Arizona |
| Alexander Berg |
University of Northwestern |
| Tate Bounds |
University of Northwestern |
| Cameron Coppock |
University of Northwestern |
| Jacob Emley |
University of Northwestern |
| Nathan Fenske |
University of Northwestern |
| Blake Mitchell |
University of Northwestern |
| Caleb Sieben |
University of Northwestern |
| David Acton |
Warner University |
| Ashton Mincey |
Warner University |
| Jonas Small |
Warner University |