| Tournament Most Outstanding Player |
| Mason Snodgrass |
Judson University |
|
|
| All-Tournament Team |
| Jack Demik |
Redeemer University |
| Grant Shipley |
Judson University |
| Mason Snodgrass |
Judson University |
| Reece Thompson |
Judson University |
| Andrew Walcott |
Redeemer University |
|
|
| Game Plan 4 LIFE Award |
| Paul Fillion |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
|
| NCCAA Coach of the Year |
| Michael Dedee |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
|
| NCCAA Player of the Year |
| Horatio Maumasi |
OUAZ |
|
| NCCAA All-America First Team |
| Horatio Maumasi |
OUAZ |
| Kevin Bryant |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Thomas Dunkley |
Bethel University |
| Jeramiah Zomerman |
Redeemer University |
| Caeden Salmen |
OUAZ |
| Jordan Hoover |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Mason Snodgrass |
Judson University |
|
| NCCAA All-America Second Team |
| Landon Brouwer |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Romone Rudolph |
Warner University |
| McGwire Eigenrauch |
Bethel University |
| Madduxx Gordon |
OUAZ |
| Santana Roybal-Benson |
Bethel University |
| Jayce Moore |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Timothy Fletcher |
Lancaster Bible College |
|
| AVCA All-America First Team |
| Landon Brouwer |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Kevin Bryant |
Lancaster Bible College |
| Thomas Dunkley |
Bethel University |
| Jordan Hoover |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Horatio Maumasi |
OUAZ |
| Romone Rudolph |
Warner University |
| Caeden Salmen |
OUAZ |
| |
|
| Scholar-Athletes |
| Timofey Borodkin |
Bethel University |
| McGwire Eigenrauch |
Bethel University |
| Jack Hughes |
Bethel University |
| Jacob Massey |
Bethel University |
| Carson Moore |
Bethel University |
| Ben Ritzema |
Bethel University |
| Friedrich Hall |
Carolina University |
| Hayden Brown |
Judson University |
| Gabriel Cantrell |
Judson University |
| Grant Shipley |
Judson University |
| Daneil Yap |
Judson University |
| Alan Greydanus |
Redeemer University |
| Ariel Downer |
Regent University |
| Keith Larkin |
Regent University |
| Preston Nemeti |
Regent University |
| Paul Fillion |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Kaidan Krchniak |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Griffin Monrad |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Nathan Worden |
Roberts Wesleyan University |
| Mehmet Ali Ceyhan |
Warner University |
| Keith Harrison |
Warner University |